Sole Trader vs Company: Which Structure Funds the Life You Want?

Flagstaff Hill lighthouse in Warrnambool, home of The Bucket List Accountant

Flagstaff Hill, Warrnambool. Photo: Adele Erolsky on Unsplash

Short answer: a sole trader structure is cheap and simple, and usually suits a business that is just starting or earning a modest profit. A company costs more to run but caps the tax rate on profits at 25% for most small businesses and puts a legal wall between the business and your personal assets. The right choice depends on your profit, your risk and what you want your life to look like.

Most business owners around Warrnambool picked their structure the day they started. Usually in a hurry. Usually because a mate said so.

Then the business grew, and nobody went back to check whether the structure still fits. That is how people end up paying more tax than they need to, carrying more risk than they realise, and telling themselves the trip to Italy can wait until retirement.

It does not have to wait. But the structure has to be working for you first.

How a sole trader is taxed

As a sole trader, you and the business are the same person in the eyes of the tax office. Every dollar of profit lands on your personal tax return and is taxed at individual rates.

For 2026-27 that means:

  • Nothing on the first $18,200

  • 15% from $18,201 to $45,000

  • 30% from $45,001 to $135,000

  • 37% from $135,001 to $190,000

  • 45% above $190,000

  • Plus the 2% Medicare levy

So the more the business makes, the bigger the slice the tax office takes. A great year can push a big chunk of your profit into the 37% or 45% brackets.

How a company is taxed

A company is its own legal entity. It lodges its own tax return and pays a flat rate on profit: 25% if it is a base rate entity, which covers most small trading companies, and 30% otherwise.

You then pay yourself a wage, dividends or both, and you pay personal tax on what you actually take out. Profit you leave in the company to fund growth stays taxed at the company rate.

That gap between 25% and 45% is where good planning lives.

It is not just about tax

Tax gets the headlines, but three other things matter just as much.

Risk. A sole trader is personally on the hook for business debts. A company gives you a layer of protection, although directors can still be personally liable in some situations, and banks often ask for personal guarantees.

Cost and admin. A company comes with set-up costs, annual ASIC fees, a separate tax return and stricter record keeping. You cannot just dip into the company bank account like it is your own wallet. The tax office has rules about that.

Selling later. Individuals and companies are treated very differently when a business is sold. If selling is on your list one day, structure matters years before the sale.

So when does a company make sense?

There is no magic number, and anyone who gives you one without seeing your figures is guessing. As a rough guide, it is worth a proper conversation when:

  • Your profit is consistently pushing into the higher tax brackets

  • You want to keep profit in the business to grow it

  • Your work carries real commercial risk

  • You are bringing in a business partner or investor

  • You are thinking about selling down the track

For plenty of local trades, farms and family businesses, a company or a company with a trust behind it ends up being the better fit. For others, staying a sole trader is the smart move. Both answers are fine. Not knowing is the expensive one.

What this has to do with your bucket list

Positano on the Amalfi Coast at dusk, a bucket list trip for business owners

Positano, Italy. Photo: Sebastian Leonhardt on Unsplash

Here is the bit most accountants skip.

The point of getting your structure right is not a neater tax return. It is the money and headspace it frees up. A few thousand dollars a year in tax saved is a family holiday. A structure that protects the house is a decent night's sleep. A business that runs properly is one you can step away from for three weeks without it falling over.

Too many people work themselves into the ground hoping they will be healthy enough to enjoy it all at 65. We would rather you did some of it now.

Frequently asked questions

Is it better to be a sole trader or a company in Australia?

Neither is better across the board. Sole trader is simpler and cheaper. A company usually wins once profit is high enough that the flat company rate and asset protection outweigh the extra cost.

What tax does a small company pay in 2026-27?

Most small trading companies pay 25% as base rate entities. Companies that do not meet the base rate entity rules pay 30%.

Can I change from a sole trader to a company later?

Yes. It needs to be planned carefully because moving assets between structures can trigger tax. There are rollover rules that can help, so get advice before you do anything.

Does a company protect my house?

It helps, but it is not bulletproof. Personal guarantees and some director obligations can still reach personal assets. Structure, insurance and how you hold assets all work together.

Ready to check yours?

If you are in Warrnambool, South West Victoria or Geelong and you have not reviewed your structure in the last few years, book a chat with David. Bring your numbers and your bucket list. We will start with the list.

This article is general information only and is not personal financial or tax advice. Talk to us about your own situation before making decisions.

Next
Next

Small Business Growth Coaching for Marketing and Finance